Famous for defining the large fast fashion chains as “shitty places”, this time he ended up in the dock. Mattia Berveglieri, an entrepreneur from Modena famous on social media for the videos in which he enters shops to criticize the labels of clothing items, is in the sights of the advertiser, trainer and creator Riccardo Pirrone. At the center of the clash, renamed ‘EtichettaGate’, are the textile certifications displayed on the website of the Numb brand – founded by Berveglieri and managed by The Factory srl – and the regularity of a prize competition.
Pirrone’s accusations: unverifiable certifications
Let’s go in order and retrace the story. The investigation, a few days ago, started from the e-commerce pages www.numb-wear.it, where various logos of international standards appear, including Oeko-Tex Standard 100, Gots (Global Organic Textile Standard), Reach, Pfoa Free, Global Recycled Standard and Leather Working Group. These are international acronyms that certify on clothing items, in various capacities, the absence of harmful chemical substances, the use of recycled components or the sustainable processing of leather. Pirrone reports that the brands are displayed both in the individual product sheets and in the automatic cart recovery emails, where the brand promises customers that “every item is certified”. Having purchased a brand t-shirt, the advertiser finds the absence of any label or identification code useful for verifying the declared certifications.
By clicking on the link to download the Oeko-Tex certificate on the site, the user instead finds a declaration made out to another company, the supplier Italiana Tessuti srl, without an identification code, analysis body and list of fabrics covered.
The official denials
Pirrone contacts the certification bodies directly to verify the position of the brand and collects responses which, according to what he reports, deny the ownership of the certifications held by the Berveglieri brand. Oeko-Tex and Centrocot, the only institute authorized in Italy for Standard 100, communicate in writing that in their systems there are no certificates registered in the name of either Numb or Italiana Tessuti srl. The bodies define the published document as an “improper use of the trademark”, send the report to their legal department and specify that it is forbidden to use the certification of individual components to promote a finished product without certification.
Icea, the certifying body for the Gots standard, expresses itself along the same lines, confirming that Numb does not appear in the official database. In the register only Italiana Tessuti srl appears, but only for the trade of unfinished fabrics. Icea clarifies that the fabric certification does not automatically transfer to the finished garment: without traceability via Transaction Certificate and with processes carried out by non-certified companies, the material loses the Gots status.
According to Pirrone, using quality brands without authorization to encourage purchases “constitutes a violation of articles 21 and 23 of the Consumer Code on deceptive commercial practices”. And here we add the reporting of possible irregularities linked to a giveaway promoted by the brand.
The first answer to the phone and removal from the site
Before making the investigation public, Pirrone contacted Berveglieri by telephone to inform him of the checks. On that occasion, the founder of Numb claims to have published the logos “naively”, claiming to have received authorization for Oeko-Tex from the supplier Italiana Tessuti srl. On the prize competition front, Berveglieri puts the responsibility back on his team and admits that the contest “may not have been registered according to the law”. Immediately after the phone call, all references to certifications are removed from the Numb website.
Berveglieri’s video reply: “Three company errors, I apologize”
After the case exploded on social media, the Modena entrepreneur published a reply video – with extremely colorful language as per his style – from his company’s warehouse. Berveglieri rejects the accusation of bad faith, explaining that Numb purchases certified fabrics from its suppliers and that months ago the company decided to upload those certifications to e-commerce to enhance the garments. “St*** was explained on the site and this was the mistake,” he declares, specifying that the same oversight was repeated on the website, in an email and in an advertisement.
While attributing the mistake to external collaborators and employees of a growing company that he cannot entirely control, Berveglieri states that he takes responsibility (“I absolutely do not downplay it”) and apologizes for what he defines as a “huge mistake” and a “badly exploited mega misunderstanding”. In the video he also claims to have removed the incorrect contents ten days earlier following a report. Finally, it shows the internal label of a wool and cashmere coat made in collaboration with a supplier specialized in wool recycling, accusing detractors of exploiting its image to generate engagement.
The controversial aftermath on shopkeepers
In another story, taken up by Pirrone himself, Berveglieri returns to the matter, minimizing the extent of the criticism. He states that the controversy has not “dented him one iota” and attacks the detractors of the fashion sector, defining them as frustrated operators with “small shops that no longer survive” and “brands that no one buys anymore”. Berveglieri then closes the case by thanking for the visibility obtained and reiterating that he believes in the value of “both positive and negative” advertising.